Francene - Views on news
  • BLOG
  • About
  • Contact

Should technology take over in schools?

6/1/2015

12 Comments

 
Picture
Robots could replace teachers as the main source of information in classrooms around the world, according to a leading academic at UK's University of Oxford.

The professor's warning about the increasing use of machines in the schoolroom will mean teachers will be less important when transmitting knowledge. These days. students absorb content better from online videos. By allowing technology's superior delivery of information, the teacher will be free to engage with students in a more interactive fashion.

But, machines can't show a deep understanding of human society. Nor can they empathize with students about their personal problems. They don't have the social intelligence required to monitor a classroom, or to inspire students struggling with a concept.

In the future, students will need to take control of their own learning. A device at each student's desk will deliver content tailored to their interest and expertise, rather than everyone receiving the same material from the teacher standing in front of the class. Source: The Telegraph.

Picture
In theory, this sounds good. Students work at their own speed, learning things they are interested in, while a teacher walks around class helping where needed. It reminds me of the experiment in Australian schools in the late sixties called 'open plan' schools.

My three children attended a new school of this type when we moved into our house at Henley Beach in South Australia. The whole infant school's learning area consisted of one big room. In each section, a teacher stood beside a blackboard or equipment speaking to students seated around a table or on the floor. Children were free to roam from one area to another, seeking the subject that held their interest. Back then, technology didn't enter the equation. As an aside, the teaching method didn't work. My son's disruptive nature, contained in his high IQ, caused more trouble than the system could handle. Rather than allowing each child to learn at their own pace, the shy ones were swamped by overbearing children. It might have suited my son to be able to learn all he needed via a screen. His life could have turned out differently before his early demise. Maybe it would suit other personalities as well, like children with attention deficiency disorder.

I can see good points in learning from technology. But how would a child balance that with his family's relationships? Would he listen when his mother or father laid down the rules? Would she appreciate her mother's guidance in personal matters? It seems to me they might reject anything we consider normal. Maybe our whole social structure would collapse without close personal ties.

But I'm a writer—a novelist. (See my books on the sidebar.) That's my creative process taking over—working out a future scenario.

Would children be more likely to be inspired by robot technology or a human teacher? Do you like the way our society is headed?


12 Comments
Alana Mautone link
5/31/2015 08:26:16 pm

As an aside, my son's middle school (in our city, grades 5, 6 and 7) was in an open plan school and it was an absolute disaster. But, as to robots replacing teachers - I am so against this for so many reasons. A robot can not tell if a student is suffering for non academic reasons. I could see robots helping to educate children with autism, however,although even here human teachers should never be replaced, only supplemented.

Reply
Sonji Dunn
5/31/2015 11:04:29 pm

I feel, in today's society, too much is being replaced by today's modern technology. While it's fantastic to be able to "search", for information for reports, remember the hard copy Brittanicas, where as a child, you actually had to read and write, to achieve? The theory of open classroom won't exist whenever our children are educated, transforming into adults, entering the workforce. The "core study " is hard enough to maneuver, assisting with today's homework, imagine if you weren't computer savvy? Good points you've made, it is my hope, the Schools will absorb the opinions of parents and guardians, our children still need a teacher with a smile and compassionate heart.

Reply
Kimberly link
5/31/2015 11:39:08 pm

There's a very interesting video about this concept on Ted Talks. I thought the idea had merit. When students are engaged in a subject that interests them they learn quickly and seek out more.
Kimberly
http://FiftyJewels.com

Reply
Mary Hill link
6/1/2015 03:34:41 am

I think robots could not replace the child's need for affirmation and love. My daughter loves her teacher because they encourage her to succeed and praise her when she does well. A robot could not replace this human interaction. Just my thoughts. :)

Reply
Laurel Regan link
6/1/2015 04:22:43 am

Technology has its place, but I don't believe it would be wise for machines to ever replace human teachers. There's more to the equation than just imparting knowledge.

Reply
Payal Agarwal link
6/1/2015 08:12:26 pm

Humans made machines to help them not to replace them. We can't depend much on such technology.Teaching is a noble profession. I don't think human teachers should ever be replaced.

Reply
Sushree Dash link
6/1/2015 08:38:04 pm

It's great machines make our lives easy but definitely at a price. I feel the more we are getting connected the more we are drifting apart.
Great post...things to ponder upon .
http://drsushreedash.blogspot.in/

Reply
GiGi Eats link
6/1/2015 10:55:01 pm

I certainly have a love-hate relationship with technology. When I went to school, I think it was the PERFECT time. Technology was certainly important but it wasn't as PARAMOUNT as it is now. We still had to go to the library and we didn't text our teachers, etc. Now it's just crazy. I can only imagine what might sprout up in a few years time!

Reply
Lata link
6/2/2015 12:36:15 am

A balance has to be found. People need people for emotional guidance and sustenance

Reply
Joan Harrington link
6/2/2015 01:59:03 am

Hey Francene,
I am afraid that this is what is going to happen in our schools, for me I would like the human interaction to remain :)

Thanks for sharing this very interesting topic :)

Reply
Cheryl Nicholl link
6/2/2015 10:05:16 am

There are just certain moments that need human interaction and TEACHING is one of them. Interesting topic. Thanks for sharing.

Reply
Parul link
6/3/2015 01:10:17 am

I see the need for technology but there has to be a balance. When Robots become Teachers, Children will not turn in to well rounded individuals..

Reply



Leave a Reply.

    Author

    Francene Stanley
    From England, I use news items in my novels which you can see below, all linked to an Amazon near you.

    Picture
    Picture
    Picture
    Picture
    Picture

    Archives

    March 2016
    February 2016
    January 2016
    November 2015
    October 2015
    September 2015
    August 2015
    July 2015
    June 2015
    May 2015
    April 2015
    March 2015
    February 2015
    January 2015

    Categories
    news
    earth
    sea
    space
    environment
    people
    animals
    fish
    birds 

    experience 
    writing
    novels

    All

    RSS Feed

Powered by Create your own unique website with customizable templates.