Francene - Views on news
  • BLOG
  • About
  • Contact

Should we look at theft a different way?

2/10/2015

8 Comments

 
PictureTower of London - en.wikipedia.org
The historic castle, Majesty's Royal Palace and Fortress, otherwise known as the Tower of London, is built on the north bank of the River Thames in central London. The river can cover the low-lying area outside the walls at high tide. Many overseas visitors are drawn to the area every year, but not all the tourists are there to gawk at the splendor.


Outside the walls of the Tower in front of Traitors' Gate, tourists were alarmed to see four men standing in the moat picking up the coins.

One man shouted at the thieves. The men looked up, apprehension in their eyes. They they took off at a run.

PictureTower moat - geograph.org.uk
But they didn't get far. Tower of London staff and army personnel detained them.

At the police station, questions revealed them to be homeless Romanians, who admitted to stealing £350 worth of coins.

Tourists visiting one of the most visited destinations in the world had thrown the money into the moat, and the donation was destined for the Royal British Legion.

I suppose the vagrants saw their chance. The coins lying on the soggy ground must have been too much of a temptation. But, however much they needed the money, taking something that didn't belong to them was theft.

On Tuesday last week, they were each given a six month conditional discharge and ordered to pay victim surcharges of £16, a very small amount for their misdemeanor.

PictureBeefeaters - geograph.org.uk
The following Friday, police made a special visit to the famous London attraction to return the cash. Officers from Tower Hamlets returned the cash to a Yeoman Warder of Her Majesty's Palace and Fortress, more commonly known as a Beefeater. In principle they are responsible for looking after any prisoners in the Tower and safeguarding the British crown jewels, but in practice they act as tour guides and are a tourist attraction in their own right, a point the Yeomen Warders acknowledge.

See the full Telegraph story.

What happened to the Romanians? Nobody said. Did they deserve to be helped out of their homeless state? I don't believe an act of charity toward them would send the right message. What do you think?


8 Comments
David link
2/9/2015 06:48:59 pm

I heard a great quote the other day along the lines of 'charitable people didn't used to do 'charity', the sought justice'.

Which makes me wonder what would justice look like in this situation? Can a company be called a charity if it wants to punish the homeless so that it can finance it's own objectives?

There is probably a much larger discussion on the idea of charity/business in the modern era but I can't help but feel that the only victims in this scenario (even if they weren't caught) are the homeless guys...

Reply
Alana link
2/9/2015 07:22:28 pm

The article didn't mention what the men were using the money for. I think I am a little confused as to if it was their first theft or not. If they were using the money for food or clothing, as they stole a little at a time, I would be sympathetic. I've become cynical when thinking of charities, too - the cancer society that had nothing for my mother in law, for example - but other people benefit tremendously from charities. So: this was theft.

Reply
Allison link
2/9/2015 08:12:45 pm

That's a tricky one. I think it's odd to fine people that have no money. Wouldn't it be better to have them do community service. Especially something that could turn into some sort of work? Just a thought.

Reply
Mel Day link
2/9/2015 08:35:36 pm

Black or white. Theft or not. Technically the coins may be considered as unclaimed. The donators cast them aside. They rest on common property. The Romanians were opportunists irrespective of their purpose for the money. Akin to looting. Disrespectful. Unconscionable perhaps. Yet in their eyes necessary.

I agree with Allison: community service would have been a better penalty.

Reply
Sophie Bowns link
2/10/2015 12:37:33 am

It's a hard one to judge. Theft is frowned upon, but some people steal because they have no choice/ no other way to feed their family.
-Remember Jean-Valjean?...

Reply
SnarkyMommaWithLove link
2/10/2015 01:59:41 pm

I cannot imagine that fining those men will do any good. They likely will be unable to pay the fine, eventually will be arrested for some other small offense,like panhandling, if they even stay in the country,and then will have to serve their six month sentence. Which will do nothing for anyone.
The legal system has no idea what to do with the homeless in any country. Yes, they need to be held responsible for the theft, but fining someone with no money is similar to telling an alcoholic not to drink and then sending him back to the bar. Both are doomed to failure.

Reply
Ina
2/11/2015 04:16:09 am

Would it be more charitable to find them some work and a place to stay but then this is something the governments are fighting everyday. There should be a base for the homeless, somewehre they can go and ask if jobs are there, not become parasites. For if they remain idle, who knows what they would turn to. We have enough stories of street boys joining the mafia without adding any more.

Reply
Inderpreet Kaur link
2/12/2015 01:43:33 pm

The Romanians were at fault but the govt should try to help them, i don't think fining them is the right thing to do. Maybe community service would have been a better option.

Reply



Leave a Reply.

    Author

    Francene Stanley
    From England, I use news items in my novels which you can see below, all linked to an Amazon near you.

    Picture
    Picture
    Picture
    Picture
    Picture

    Archives

    March 2016
    February 2016
    January 2016
    November 2015
    October 2015
    September 2015
    August 2015
    July 2015
    June 2015
    May 2015
    April 2015
    March 2015
    February 2015
    January 2015

    Categories
    news
    earth
    sea
    space
    environment
    people
    animals
    fish
    birds 

    experience 
    writing
    novels

    All

    RSS Feed

Powered by Create your own unique website with customizable templates.